3 Mic Podcast Setup: How to Decide How Many Hosts Your Podcast Should Have
You've got a brilliant concept for a podcast, you've brainstormed potential episode topics, and you're brimming with excitement to share your ideas with the world. But as you start to plan the logistics, you hit a roadblock: how many hosts should your podcast have? Should you brave the airwaves solo, team up with a co-host, or gather a panel of voices? This decision can significantly impact your podcast's format, dynamics, and overall success.
In this comprehensive guide, we'll explore the pros and cons of different host configurations, helping you make an informed decision that aligns with your podcast's goals and your personal strengths. We'll delve into the nuances of solo hosting, co-hosting, and multi-host setups, providing insights and examples to guide you through this crucial decision-making process.
Understanding the Impact of Host Numbers
Before we dive into the specifics of each hosting configuration, it's essential to understand how the number of hosts can affect various aspects of your podcast:
Content Delivery: The number of hosts influences how information is presented and discussed.
Audience Engagement: Different host setups can create varying levels of connection with listeners.
Production Complexity: More hosts generally mean more complex recording and editing processes.
Show Dynamics: The interaction between hosts can significantly impact the energy and flow of your podcast.
Consistency: Multiple hosts require coordination, which can affect your ability to maintain a regular publishing schedule.
With these factors in mind, let's explore the golden rule of podcast hosting and then dive into the specifics of each hosting configuration.
Understanding Podcast Hosting Options
Podcast hosting is a crucial aspect of creating and distributing a podcast. It refers to the service that stores and distributes your podcast files, making them accessible to listeners through various platforms such as Apple Podcasts, Spotify, and Google Podcasts.
What is a podcast host?
A podcast host is a service that provides storage and distribution for your podcast files. Think of it as the home base for your podcast, where all your episodes are stored and managed. A good podcast host ensures that your audio files are reliably stored and easily accessible, allowing you to focus on creating content rather than worrying about technical issues.
Types of podcast hosts
There are several types of podcast hosts available, each with its own set of features and pricing plans. Here are some popular options:
Media hosting platforms: These platforms specialize in hosting media files, including podcasts. Examples include Libsyn, Buzzsprout, and Podbean. They offer robust features like detailed analytics, monetization options, and easy distribution to major podcast directories.
Website builders: Some website builders, such as WordPress and Wix, offer podcast hosting services as part of their packages. This can be a convenient option if you want to manage your website and podcast in one place.
Podcast-specific platforms: Platforms like Anchor and Spotify offer podcast hosting services specifically designed for podcasters. These platforms often provide user-friendly interfaces and additional tools for podcast creation and promotion.
When choosing a podcast host, consider factors such as storage space, bandwidth, customer support, and pricing. It’s essential to select a host that meets your podcast’s needs and budget. A reliable podcast host can make a significant difference in the ease of managing and growing your podcast.
The Golden Rule: Four's a Crowd
In the world of podcasting, there's an unwritten rule that echoes an age-old saying: "If two's company and three's a crowd, then four's way too many." This isn't just a catchy phrase; it's a principle grounded in the realities of audio-based media.
Why the Limit?
Voice Differentiation: Podcasts are purely auditory experiences. Listeners rely solely on voices and context clues to distinguish between speakers. With three or fewer voices, most listeners can keep track. Add a fourth (or more), and it becomes challenging for the audience to follow who's saying what.
Conversation Flow: More voices mean more potential for interruptions, talking over each other, or awkward silences as hosts try to avoid stepping on each other's toes.
Content Focus: With too many hosts, discussions can easily veer off-topic, making it difficult to maintain a coherent narrative or deliver valuable content to your audience.
Technical Challenges: Recording and editing become exponentially more complex with each additional host, especially if you're recording remotely.
Exceptions to the Rule
While the three-host limit is a good general guideline, there are always exceptions:
Panel Shows: Some successful podcasts, like "The Guilty Feminist" or "Wait Wait... Don't Tell Me!", feature larger panels. However, these shows often have a strong moderator and a well-defined structure to manage multiple voices.
Rotating Hosts: Some podcasts have a larger pool of hosts but only feature 2-3 per episode, allowing for variety while maintaining clarity.
Special Episodes: Occasionally bringing in additional voices for special episodes can add variety without compromising your regular format.
Remember, even shows with multiple regular hosts often adapt when bringing in guests. For example, in three-host shows like "Pod Save America," one or two hosts typically step back when a guest joins to maintain that optimal number of voices.
Determining Your Podcast Type
The type of podcast you’re creating should heavily influence your decision about the number of hosts. Let’s explore common podcast formats and their typical hosting setups:
Interview-Driven Podcasts: These podcasts feature a host who interviews different guests in each episode. The host should ensure that guests have external microphones, such as dynamic microphones, for improved sound capture and better audio quality. This format often requires good preparation and research to ask insightful questions and keep the conversation engaging.
Conversational/Discussion Podcasts: These podcasts typically have two or more hosts who engage in a discussion on various topics. The ease of using USB microphones makes them ideal for such setups, as they are plug-and-play and suitable for recording multiple voices. This format thrives on the chemistry and rapport between the hosts, making it essential to choose co-hosts who can maintain a lively and interesting dialogue.
1. Interview-Driven Podcasts
Typical Host Count: 1-2 hosts + guest
Examples:
“Armchair Expert” with Dax Shepard
“The Tim Ferriss Show”
“Fresh Air” with Terry Gross
Why It Works: A single host (or occasionally two) allows for focused, in-depth conversations with guests. The host(s) can develop a consistent interview style and build a rapport with the audience, while guests provide fresh perspectives each episode.
Considerations:
Solo hosting requires strong interviewing skills and the ability to carry a conversation.
Two hosts can provide different perspectives and help keep the conversation flowing, but require good chemistry and clear roles.
Using dynamic microphones is important to ensure clear and high-quality audio during interviews.
2. Conversational/Discussion Podcasts
Typical Host Count: 2-3 hosts
Examples:
"My Favorite Murder" with Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark
"Pod Save America" with Jon Favreau, Jon Lovett, and Tommy Vietor
"Stuff You Should Know" with Josh Clark and Charles W. "Chuck" Bryant
Why It Works: Multiple hosts create a dynamic conversation that can feel like listeners are part of a friend group. Different perspectives can lead to interesting discussions and debates.
Considerations:
Chemistry between hosts is crucial.
Clearly defined roles or areas of expertise for each host can help maintain structure.
With three hosts, be prepared to manage conversation flow to avoid talking over each other.
3. Narrative/Educational Podcasts
Typical Host Count: 1 host (sometimes with supporting voices)
Examples:
"99% Invisible" with Roman Mars
"Revisionist History" with Malcolm Gladwell
"Hardcore History" with Dan Carlin
Why It Works: A single, authoritative voice can effectively guide listeners through complex topics or narratives. It allows for a consistent tone and pacing throughout the series.
Considerations:
Requires strong scripting and storytelling skills.
The host needs to be comfortable carrying the show solo.
Consider incorporating interviews or guest expert segments to add variety.
4. News and Current Affairs Podcasts
Typical Host Count: 1-3 hosts
Examples:
"The Daily" (The New York Times) with Michael Barbaro
"Up First" (NPR) with rotating hosts
"Global News Podcast" (BBC) with rotating hosts
Why It Works: News podcasts often benefit from multiple perspectives, but a single authoritative host can also effectively deliver daily news updates.
Considerations:
Multiple hosts can provide different areas of expertise and perspectives on complex issues.
For daily news podcasts, having multiple hosts can help manage the workload of frequent episodes.
A single host can provide consistency and build a strong connection with the audience.
5. Comedy Podcasts
Typical Host Count: 2-3 hosts
Examples:
"Conan O'Brien Needs a Friend" with Conan O'Brien and assistant Sona Movsesian
"2 Dope Queens" with Phoebe Robinson and Jessica Williams
"The Joe Rogan Experience" with Joe Rogan (solo host but often with guests)
Why It Works: Comedy often thrives on interaction and banter, which is why many comedy podcasts feature multiple hosts or a host-sidekick dynamic.
Considerations:
Chemistry and timing between hosts are crucial for comedy.
Even solo comedy hosts often incorporate guests or a "straight man" figure to play off of.
Be prepared for longer editing sessions to nail comedic timing and remove jokes that don't land.
The Pros and Cons of Different Host Numbers and Sound Quality
Now that we've explored how host numbers typically align with different podcast types, let's break down the pros and cons of each configuration:
Solo Hosting with a USB Microphone
Pros:
Complete creative control
Easier scheduling and production
Strong personal brand building
Intimate connection with the audience
Simplifies the technical aspects of recording
Cons:
Pressure to carry the entire show
Can be lonely or isolating
Lack of immediate feedback or bounce ideas off
Potentially less dynamic than multi-host shows
No backup if you're sick or unavailable
Two Hosts
Pros:
Natural conversation and banter
Shared workload for research and production
Can appeal to a broader audience with different perspectives
Built-in support system
Easier to maintain energy throughout longer episodes
Cons:
Requires finding a co-host with good chemistry
Potential for creative differences
More complex scheduling
Need to balance airtime between hosts
More complicated editing process
Three Hosts with Multiple Microphones
Pros:
Diverse perspectives and expertise
Can create a "roundtable" feel
Allows for occasional absence without derailing the show
Potential for interesting group dynamics
Can divide roles (e.g., host, researcher, producer) more easily
Cons:
Risk of crosstalk and interruptions
More difficult to achieve equal airtime
Increased production complexity
Potential for "majority rule" decisions
Can be overwhelming for listeners to keep track of multiple voices
Recording and Equipment Considerations
Recording high-quality audio is crucial for creating an engaging and professional-sounding podcast. The right equipment can make a significant difference in the sound quality of your podcast.
Choosing the right equipment for your podcast
When it comes to recording a podcast, you’ll need a few essential pieces of equipment. Here are some factors to consider:
Microphone: A good quality microphone is essential for capturing clear and crisp audio. Popular options include USB microphones like the Blue Yeti or Rode NT-USB. These USB microphones are user-friendly and provide excellent sound quality, making them ideal for beginners and experienced podcasters alike.
Audio interface: An audio interface connects your microphone to your computer and allows you to record high-quality audio. Popular options include the Focusrite Scarlett series or the PreSonus AudioBox. An audio interface is particularly useful if you plan to use multiple microphones or need to record individual audio tracks.
Headphones: Good quality headphones are essential for monitoring your audio and catching any mistakes or issues during recording. They help ensure that you can hear every detail and make necessary adjustments in real-time.
Pop filter: A pop filter reduces plosive sounds (like “p” and “t”) and helps to prevent distortion. This simple accessory can significantly improve the clarity of your recordings.
Boom arm: A boom arm allows you to position your microphone correctly and reduce vibrations. It also helps keep your recording space organized and free from clutter.
When choosing equipment, consider your budget, the type of podcast you’re creating, and the sound quality you want to achieve. Investing in a good quality microphone and audio interface is crucial to ensure your podcast sounds professional.
In addition to equipment, consider the following recording tips:
Record in a quiet room with minimal background noise to ensure clear audio.
Use a digital recorder or audio interface to record individual audio tracks, which makes editing easier.
Invest in a good quality microphone and audio interface to enhance sound quality.
Use headphones to monitor your audio and catch any mistakes during recording.
Record in a lossless format (like WAV or AIFF) to ensure high-quality audio files.
By investing in the right equipment and following these recording tips, you can create a high-quality podcast that engages and retains your listeners. Whether you’re using multiple USB microphones or a sophisticated audio interface, the key is to prioritize sound quality and minimize background noise for the best listener experience.
Considering Your Podcast Length
The length of your podcast episodes is another crucial factor in determining how many hosts you should have. Different host configurations lend themselves to different episode lengths:
Short-Form Podcasts (Under 20 minutes)
For bite-sized episodes, a single host often works best. Short-form podcasts are typically tightly scripted and focused, which aligns well with solo hosting. Examples include daily news updates or quick tip shows.
Considerations for short-form podcasts:
Scripting becomes crucial to pack value into a short time frame.
A single host can maintain a consistent pace and tone.
Multiple hosts might struggle to find their rhythm in such a short format.
Medium-Length Podcasts (20-45 minutes)
This length works well for both solo and multi-host setups. It's long enough for meaningful conversations between co-hosts but still manageable for a well-prepared solo host.
Considerations for medium-length podcasts:
Solo hosts need to be adept at maintaining energy and interest throughout.
Two hosts can create a dynamic back-and-forth that keeps listeners engaged.
Three hosts can work but require careful management of conversation flow.
Long-Form Podcasts (45+ minutes)
Longer episodes often benefit from multiple hosts or a single host with guests. The variety of voices helps maintain listener interest over an extended period.
Considerations for long-form podcasts:
Solo hosting requires significant preparation and the ability to carry extended monologues.
Multiple hosts can share the burden of filling longer episodes with engaging content.
Consider incorporating segment breaks or topic changes to maintain structure.
Remember, exceptional podcasters like Dan Carlin can hold audience attention for hours with solo narration, but this is a rare skill that takes time to develop. Most podcasters find it easier to maintain energy and interest with a co-host for longer episodes.
Making Your Decision: A Step-by-Step Guide to Record a Podcast
Now that we've explored the various factors influencing host numbers, let's walk through a step-by-step process to help you make your decision:
Define Your Podcast's Purpose: What's the primary goal of your podcast? To educate? Entertain? Inspire? Your purpose can guide your hosting choice.
Identify Your Target Audience: Consider what your ideal listeners would prefer. Some audiences connect better with a single authoritative voice, while others enjoy the dynamics of multiple hosts.
Assess Your Personal Strengths and Weaknesses: Be honest about your abilities. Are you comfortable carrying a show solo? Do you thrive on interaction?
Consider Your Resources: Think about time commitments, scheduling complexities, and production capabilities. Multiple hosts require more coordination but can share the workload.
Experiment with Different Formats: If possible, record test episodes with different host configurations. See what feels most natural and engaging.
Seek Feedback: Share your test episodes with trusted friends or fellow podcasters. Their input can provide valuable insights.
Plan for the Long Term: Consider sustainability. Choose a format you can maintain consistently over many episodes.
Be Open to Evolution: Remember, you're not locked into your initial choice forever. Many successful podcasts have adjusted their hosting setup over time.
Conclusion: Embrace Your Unique Voice(s)
Choosing the number of hosts for your podcast is a pivotal decision, but it's not an immutable one. The most successful podcasts are those that authentically represent their creators' voices and effectively serve their audience's needs.
Whether you decide to go solo, pair up with a co-host, or gather a trio of voices, remember that content quality, consistency, and genuine passion for your topic are the true determinants of podcast success. Your hosting configuration should enhance these elements, not detract from them.
As you embark on your podcasting journey, remain flexible and open to feedback. Don't be afraid to adjust your format if you find certain aspects aren't working as well as you'd hoped. The beauty of podcasting lies in its adaptability and the direct connection you can forge with your audience.
Ultimately, the right number of hosts for your podcast is the one that allows you to create compelling content consistently while enjoying the process. Trust your instincts, consider your audience, and most importantly, have fun with it. Happy podcasting!
LIKED THIS ARTICLE? DOWNLOAD OUR FREE PODCASTING GUIDES
Guide to Growth & Monetization The Ultimate Production Checklist Vocal Warm-ups for Podcasters Target Listener Persona Template